patching...
Update: Spread the word about Cranberry Patch in the community! Follow us on Twitter and on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/CranberryPatch »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Should Local School Districts Open Their Own Cyber Schools?

Neshannock Township School District is offering its own online learning academy to compete with other nonprofit and for-profit cyber charter schools.

 

Reasons vary as to why people decide to enroll their children in cyber schools.

For some, it's to avoid disciplinary and behavior problems they feel are rampant in the brick-and-mortar school. Others feel their child is not thriving in public school and choose cyber school instead of charter, private or parochial options.

Regardless of the reason, almost 30,000 students in Pennsylvania are being served by cyber schools, according to the Commonwealth Foundation. Cyber schools remain controversial, though, in terms of real student success, costs and the money they drain from public schools.

Neshannock Township School District, located just north of New Castle, seems to have come up with a way to keep that money in-house while still providing students residing in the district with an online learning option.

According to a video on the district website, Neshannock School District Online Learning Academy for grades K-12 is an "extention of district's educational offerings." Students who enroll and live in Neshannock can get support services and use district resources because they are close to home. The cyber students stay on track with instruction at the school and can participate in the district's extracurricular activities.

They even have live tutors available from 2 p.m. to 1 a.m. At the end, they also get a Neshannock diploma. But best of all for Pittsburgh area residents, they accept the state's opportunity scholarship money available to students in "failing" districts.

Posters for the online learning academy have made their way as far south as the Woodland Hills School District. One has been hanging in the Kuhn's Market bulletin board in Wilkins Township for more than a week.

Woodland Hills School Board member Tara Reis blogged on Patch earlier this year and said that since the 2005-06 school year, her district has shelled out more than $47 million for charter and cyber charter schools, but been reimbursed only $7.5 million of that. The 2011-12 school year cost Woodland Hills $12 million with $0 reimbursement, Reis said.

A district-run online academy might keep some of that money at home for Woodland Hills and other districts in western Pennsylvania. It would also allow students to feel more a part of the district in which they live.

Gateway School District in Monroeville already has the Gateway Cyber Academy for grades 9-12. Seneca Valley also instituted its own cyber school.

So, do you see a district-run online academy as a way for your school district to keep from losing money as the next generation increasingly turns to cyberspace vs. classrooms?

Take our poll and let us know why in the comments section.

  • Should Local School Districts Open Their Own Cyber Schools?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes, school districts should offer this option to keep the money paid to cyber schools in the district's coffers.
        24 (52%)
    • No, local school districts should focus on classroom education and leave cyber education for profit and nonprofit businesses and organizations.
        17 (36%)
    • This is definitely a choice worth my district exploring.
        5 (10%)
    Total votes: 46
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Cyber schools, Neshannock Township School District, Online Learning, Public Schools, and cyber charter school

Laura Nickel

12:14 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

These numbers dont add up. If 30,000 kids in all of Pa were cyber schooled, how did woodland hills loose 45 million. And if they got 7.5 million for kids they weren't even schooling, then why is this a problem? Maybe woodland hills should use the money they have more efficiently like the private sector has to.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Zandy Dudiak

1:03 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

Laura, the Woodland Hills money was for both charter and cyber charter schools, not just cyber schools.

Reply

Jon Wain

3:51 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

i read the post in the patch here and would have to say that cyber school may be the way to go.it gets the district of the hook with poor test scores and if lunch sucks ,,blame the parent. And ya keep your kids from socializing with other kids face to face.like the classroom .make them make friends on the net .

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

4:03 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

Jon, do you know that students that go to cyber school are also allowed to play all sports at their local schools. They join little league, hockey. football teams in their community. They don't have to make friends on the net People now are optioning for cyber schools because of school districts like Baldwin who's ratings keep on going down and unless they change members on the school board and the administration then it will continue to send more children to charter and cyber schools

Jon Wain

8:46 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

too bad we can't get a tax break if your kid gets schooled in space.but the poor child will still have to buy his helmets and other game needs that our school dosen't provide.AAgree cc we need board members with b___s

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

1:31 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

We need new board members at Baldwin along with a better Administration. They care more about videos and making the schools pretty instead of giving our kids an education.

Mana

9:53 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

Absolutely not! I removed my child from the public school for academic reasons, why would I want them back into the same failing system?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Marianna

10:52 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

Mana, I've always wondered...how do you help keep your kids socialized with other kids their age? I'm not sure how old your kids are, but do they participate in after school sports, activities?

Comment_arrow

Mana

10:56 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

Marianna, yes, they play sports, scouts (wonderful organization) and church. plus, having 4 children, they have each other to socialize with. if you can get along with your siblings you can get along with anyone!

thanks for asking!

Comment_arrow

cc

1:33 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Marianna they are still entitled to play sports for the school districts after all the school district keeps 20% of the money from each student for that reason. the students that goes to cyber school usually get testing done at the school district too.

Kristilee Williams

11:09 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

We love our cyber charter school. Wouldn't change to a public school for anything. All my kids hear about from their public schooled friends is the amount of bullyling, fighting, and fear and stress experienced on a daily basis. If that is what passes for "socialization" then I'm happy to keep my kids away from it. I don't think the public schools would be able to do cyber education in the engaging, amazing way our cyber school does it. No two kids learn best exactly the same way, or in the same kind of environment. What works for some kids and families doesn't work for others. I think the more choices we have to find a good fit for our children and families, the better.

Reply

disappointed

12:59 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

I don't know how public schools can complain about having to pay charter and cyber schools for children they aren't even teaching. They are still getting to keep a portion of the money even though that childI isn't even even being taught there . If that same child moved to another district they wouldn't get any money for that child. They should just concentrate on making the schools better instead of spreading themselves thinner by making a cyber school.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sue T

11:36 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

I agree with you Disappointed. And, ML, the factors you listed are factors that need to be accounted for in the school budgets. Have you looked at WH's enrollment/ It's gone down 30 percent in the last 7 or 8 yrs. There is absolutely no reason they should continue to operate on the same budget.

Comment_arrow

cc

1:39 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Sue, ml doesn't even have children in the school district and she post parts of articles to make herself seem smart but you need to go read the whole article. The schools keep 20% of them money for each student that goes to cyber or charters schools. Is that fair to the parents that opted to send their children elsewhere, no it isn't Cyber students go on field trips and do things outside of sitting in front of a computer Students from Baldwin who go to charter and cyber schools are getting a better education that what Baldwin is providing.

Comment_arrow

cc

6:03 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

WH is Woodland Hills school district. A two year old could figure that one out.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

8:11 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I guess that makes you a two year old.

Comment_arrow

cc

8:25 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

NE12Ukid and your alias ml are a lmfaooooooooooo. you two haven't even gotten off a baby bottle yet.

Reba

7:20 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

I think that if they keep they cyber schooling it should be more regulated. I know personally people who abuse it. Parents doing the work etc.. all kids should go to school unless for extreme circumstances. like work, or handicaps etc...

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mana

10:17 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

and you don't think that happens in brick and mortal schools? parents have been doing the work since time began. Parents and children need options. My children are gifted and not challenged. Cyber school lets them work at their own pace and not of the pace determined by the slowest moving child.

and no, a B&M school cannot do a cyber school better only worse because they are only in it for the money, not the educational needs. If B&M schools would put ALL children's needs first and not just autistic, maybe these children would not be filing out the doors.

Comment_arrow

cc

6:09 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Reba parents who have kids in public and private schools help their children with work, and no difference. Going to cyber school is just like going to public school, they start at 8 am in the morning, have 45 minute classes, get 5 minutes between classes to use the bathroom and then they are back to learning. They do teaching though a program like Skype, teachers take enrollment and knows when students aren't their at their desk. Students and parents can also be held accountable at the magistrate if their students misses the same requirements as in a public school. Plus with cyber school they learn better then the Students do at Baldwin

Comment_arrow

Reba's Pet Service

8:42 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Help kids yes, all parents should help there child with work and teach them how to get and find the answers themselves but I'm talking a student who put off doing work all together and then they all banned together to get it done. Parents and friends completed the assignments completely on there own, while the student worked on other late and non -completed assignments. This doesn't teach our children anything positive except maybe teamwork. I'm not saying all students and parents do this, Im saying that some do and that should not be acceptable. I think the system needs to be looked at is all I'm saying.

Mana

10:19 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

Zandy, I bet if you asked, PA Cyber or any other cyber school would let you spend the day in the offices or with a cyberschooled child to see how it really works. . . It is interesting to see all these negative comments from individuals who haven't even seen the way things are done at cyber school (NOT referring to the author)

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:14 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Any Parent can call a cyber school and make an appointment to see how it i ran, can sit in classrooms to see how they teach.

Comment_arrow

Mana

12:51 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Isn't it funny how caught up people get about the financials of cyber schools, but not of B&M schools?

Bob Zanakis

10:30 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

I have mixed emotions on this topic. I don't like school taxes that support public education going to private for profit cyber schools. The next step in this progression of raiding the public's tax dollar would be to pay for private schools that are either religious or secular. Where will it end? It will end up destroying public education.

Conversely, it seems the educational system is not working at its optimum level creating a demand for alternative educational venues. In this case, I can see everyone wanting what is best for their children. Why not address the problem instead of privatization of the public school system? Taking much needed funding from a public school is not the answer to the problem, it is only making it worse.

Don't know what the real answer is given this current adimistration's lack of concern regarding the public school systems in the commonwealth as Governor Corbett and the Republican controlled legislature would rather take a billion dollars of educational funding and convert it to tax giveaways to private corporations. Stealing our tax dollars for the betterment of corporations is wrong but with the set up of the election process that gives benefits for campaign contributions is probably the motivation of the governor. Basically our politicians today are bought and paid for by private businesses whose only concern is making a profit and not for the welfare of the common man.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Don Boyle

1:00 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

I agree with you Bob, tax dollars should not go to For Profit Schools and take away from the Public system. If parent what to send their children to Cyber or another school other than public then they should fork over the cash themselves.

Comment_arrow

cc

12:27 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Baldwin Whitehall isn't providing "Then the public schools would not have enough money to provide a decent education for anyone." Parents have a right to choose to send their child to Baldwin Whitehall or a cyber or charter school. but once again blah blah blah blah blah. It would be nice if we lived in a school district that cares about our children EDUCATION, but since we don't more power to the Parents who choose to send their student to Charter and Cyber School. Maybe one day Baldwin will wake up and decide our children educations comes first.

Comment_arrow

David N. Hommrich

8:53 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Hi Mr. Zanakis. Just wanted to point out that there are no for-profit cyber charter schools in Pennsylvania. The PA Charter School Code defines a Cyber Charter School as follows:

"Cyber charter school" shall mean an independent public school established and operated under a charter from the Department of Education and in which the school uses technology in order to provide a significant portion of its curriculum and to deliver a significant portion of instruction to its students through the Internet or other electronic means. A cyber charter school must be organized as a public, nonprofit corporation. A charter may not be granted to a for-profit entity.

Charter and Cyber Charter schools are absolutely competitors to traditional public schools, which was the whole point in creating them. Competition is good, and we as consumers always win when there is healthy competition. But PA charter schools are not for-profit........never have been. Just wanted to clarify that.

Comment_arrow

Matt A.

10:23 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

I have mixed emotions about the school taxes we are paying to educate the students in Baldwin/Whitehall and they keep on pulling money away from education and hiring dean of students. Cutting the budget for technology when more money should be placed into it. If parents choose to send their child to cyber or charter school because of a better education why should we be complaining. After all they are paying school taxes probably before their children were of school age and will be paying them long after their children graduate. Taxes don't stop just because you don't have students in the school. Some people don't want to be paying these taxes now as they don't have children in the district but it was ok when other peoples taxes were paying for their students to be in school.

Mana

10:59 am on Monday, September 10, 2012

Bob it is a never ending cycle of not having enough money. in my children's home B&M school, when you ask for any time of enrichment or accleration for gifted children there isn't any money. At PA Cyber, the accleration is natual built into the self paced class. Put it to you this way, my son has already completed at least one unit in every subject. I doubt his peers in public school are moving at this pace.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

5:16 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Are you saying that children who have actually been tested and met the criteria for gifted are given no enrichment or acceleration? Or are you just talking about kids who might be bright, but not actually gifted.
Do you know the difference?

Comment_arrow

Mana

8:59 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Yes, i know the difference between gifted and bright. Two of my children are considered gifted, one has a mensa level iq. the mensa level iq, reads at a 6th -8 grade level, yet every reading activity is at a 3rd grade level (current classroom). Left behind? YES!

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

10:48 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Mana, I ONLY ASKED because if a child has been tested and identified as GIFTED in PA, they get a GIEP. Not all states provide an IEP for gifted exceptionalities, but PA does.

Comment_arrow

Ed M

6:55 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Mana,

Since you have a gifted children you should know about I.E.P's for gifted children. Use that to get what you want for your kids.

Comment_arrow

Mana

7:16 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Yes, the boys do have GIEP but it is really difficult to get anything meaningful put in because the school adds qualifying restrictions. For example, for math compacting (not acceleration) the child has to score a 93% or above. This doesn't reflect his ability to work faster than his peers or understand something deeper only that he knows the material.

Then there are other competition based items. The gifted students compete against the entire school. Highest PSSA score goes...

I am a huge fan of cyber schools because they go at their own pace as deep and as fast as they want can ( while being lead by their parents)

Comment_arrow

Ed M

8:31 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Since this is an Individualized Education Plan, that is what it should be. I have 2 deaf kids (now grown) and did more than my fair share of I.E.P.'s. The key word is Individualized. Just because everyone else has something in their I.E.P. doesn't mean your kid has to have it.

PghFan

12:39 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Mark Twain quoted, "I have never let my schooling interfere with my education." So why should where you learn be more of an issue than what you learn?

Children these days have so many opportunities with their education. They may not thrive in a typical brick and mortar school. They may be subject to bullying or attention deficit. As is the case with my cousin’s children, they were not being challenged enough by their teachers and elected to be cyber schooled. We shouldn't say get rid of our school districts, as some children do well in this environment.

From the PATCH article last week about Whitehall and Baldwin High school with poor results, why not explore cyber schools? It may not be the best option for Baldwin-Whitehall’s School Board, but it would be best for the children.

Teachers love homework, structure, activities, and projects. We love to assign, critique, build, and mold. We test, retest, demand, and push. But sometimes, it may be helpful to realize that we [adults] may be getting in the way of someone’s education. These demands in the classroom may not be laying the foundations for growth of that particular student, and sometimes, the most important thing for a school to do may be to just get out of the way.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:19 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

With all the cuts to education at Baldwin, parents are better off sending their children to cyber school.

seen2mch

3:11 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

I`ve always remained mostly nuetral towards charter/for profit schooling. It was something that was simply not available back in the days of my education. I do wonder now about how different I would be had I not been exposed to and taught by many wonderful teachers who opened my eyes to many things and were huge factors in my character development as well as becoming who I am today. And what would I have missed had I not been exposed to my fellow students,some who have been lifelong friends,and learning by seeing things through their perspectives,methods,ideas? I have observed a general lack of social and people skills in young people over the years. I understand that public/brick and mortar schools cant be all things to all people but shouldn`t socialization,dealing with bullies,liars ,cheaters,personal conflicts and the like..also be a part of our education process? It`s not as though this all disappears when we leave school. These are things you`ll have to deal with all through life. Do you want to raise your kids to hide from problems and people or do you want them to be prepared for the inevitable time when you won`t be around to help or shield them? Could this be one of the reasonst there is so much social discourse in our country? People dont get to experience any cultural or racial diversity and they are socially stunted ..thus being unable or unwilling to deal with or understand anyone who is different or thinks different than them. Just sayin.....

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:22 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Be honest how many kids do you see outside playing, Most kids sit at home on their gaming systems talking to their friends or texting on cell phones. We have about 20 children on our street and none are outside, once in awhile you will see a parent outside teaching a child how to ride a bike but not very often. Back in the days, we came home from school, did homework and then were outside till dinner time, then back outside till the streetlights came on. In this day and age very few are outside

Mary

4:26 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

One thing that they need to regulate is to be sure that the child taking the cyberclass and the tests are really that child. I know of a family where the kid took a cyber class, and a sibling took the class in place of the student so that he could pass it.....and the parents permitted it!

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:24 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Most cyber schools use programs like Skype to make sure the student is in class and they use microphones to answer teachers questions.

SWYKLocal

5:13 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

We all need to make sure our children get educated and I believe cyber schooling is the way of the future. The cyber school approach should not be duplicated by every district. In fact, the notion of cyber schools reinvented by every district is a massive waste of education resources and tax payer money.

We need to reduce the cost of education at the K-12 and college levels – this is the key to our future economic stability.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

7:36 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

swyklocal, I agree with you there. My grandson who is in 1st grade is reading on a 4th grade level and doing math on a 3rd grade level. My son and daughter in law started teaching him how to read and do math before he was 3 years old School districts don't t have the resources to keep up with children who are above their grade level and they have no clue what to do in teaching them. He is in cyber school down in VA and he is being taught on 3 different grade levels. He also goes twice a week up to the Public School for Gym Class. He is also involved with sports at the public school and is participating in track.

disappointed

7:58 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Bob...why shouldn't my child have the right to chose the school he wants to go to? Mine goes to a Charter School. She isn't hiding from the bullies etc. They still have them there. But they are less tolerant because there are many other students on the waiting list to get in so that child could easily be replaced. Also by having a choice it keeps the Charter School more on their toes because they have to make they students and parents happy to keep the demandtax for theyou students coming to their school. Again, I don't know why regular public thinks they are losing all this money. If my taxes just followed my child to the Charter School instead of going to their home district school first then they wouldn't even know it was missing. Why should public schools get paid for a service they are not providing?!

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

9:35 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

disappointed I totally agree and that is why the Government need to have a voucher program. If they want the students to enroll in local schools then they would put more money into educating our children instead wasting 20,000 to make a video to attract people to buy homes in Baldwin/Whitehall School District which was a big flop.. They wouldn't be wasting money on Dean of Sports, cutting the Technology Department. The school would be working to make Baldwin a top 10 school district. People voted for these people to be on the school board and we need to vote them out and get new people in their place that want to better our children education instead of hiding everything behind close doors.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

10:51 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

<< If my taxes just followed my child to the Charter School instead of going to their home district school first then they wouldn't even know it was missing. >>>

But in most cases what goes to the cyber charter is more than was paid by that parent in taxes per child.

Comment_arrow

JS

9:20 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

CC - You convince me that the Baldwin school district is not doing a very good job every time you post.

Comment_arrow

cc

8:34 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

NE12Ukid, yes I did graduate from Baldwin. I also had 4 children go though the district and one is there now. Big difference in Education from when my Oldest graduated in 2001 till now. Back then a house wouldn't last on the market more than 2 weeks. Now homes in Baldwin/Whitehall can sit on the market for a year. Over the last year 5 houses have been put on the market, 2 sold so far. 2 of the houses were given back to the banks after the owners purchases homes in other districts (Peters and Bethel Park), the one next to me is empty and been keeping an eye on it for them and they are paying my daughter to cut the grass once a week.

Jon Wain

8:49 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

cc in the past i've wanted to choke you BUT you are on top of things.your absolutly right about kids activities.many parents don't mind their kids on the phone or net ,,after all it allows the parent to do their own socializing at the bar or the gym.cc you see the colors the picture is painted with.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

9:24 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Jon I don't know how to take you either and want to choke you so were even. But I do think kids do need to get off the net, way from gaming systems, away from the tv and get outside and exercise. Being a widow and raising 5 children on my own wasn't easy as they were all in different sports and we were always on the go from one field to another, swim meets to track. Now that I only have one left at home I do miss all the chaos that went with all 5 of them being at home and trying to be in 5 different places at the same time. I enjoy now though when I'm not busy with my daughters swimming and track. I feel blessed now that I can still go and watch 12 of my grand children play sports or pack up their bikes in the back of the truck and head out to different trails and go bike riding with them so we all can go and get some old fashion exercising in.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

10:52 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Mrs Obama would be proud of your family exercise.

Comment_arrow

cc

6:27 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

ne12ukid, I can thank the Republicans for what I accomplished plus with being a Business Owner. According to obama, I didn't create my own business, he had a hand in it. But sorry to say that since he has been president I have lost money, since everything has gone up from GAS, utilities, car maintenance, cost of medical went up 37.38% since obamacare was put into place. The profit sharing that I do for employ. So don't tell me michelle would be proud, because I am ashamed of them on how they are destroying this Great Land.

cc

9:44 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Homestead cyber school unionizes; union says it's a first

"HARRISBURG, Pa. — Teachers at a western Pennsylvania-based cyber charter school have voted to unionize, becoming the first such school to do so in the United States, according to a labor leader.
The faculty at Homestead-based PA Learners Online voted 42-14 Monday to have the Pennsylvania State Education Association represent 76 teachers, counselors and other workers at the school, the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board said Wednesday.
"It is clear these public school employees desire the same voice in their working conditions as other school employees across the commonwealth," said James P. Testerman, president of the statewide teachers' union."
Read more: http://triblive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/news/education/s_629888.html#ixzz267aZgdYy

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ed M

6:56 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

That will hamper the productivity.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

6:19 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

This may be the first CYBER charter to unionize, but not the first charter school.

SWYKLocal

10:39 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Good link cc - too bad for them. One thing to note, 76 teachers for 660 students seems high. Each teach should be able to handle about 40 students in a cyber-environment.

We need to pay attention to this new opportunity - cost per student once this gains momentum should be no more than 8K.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

8:41 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Why should it be any different then what a school like Baldwin Charges. Cyber/Charter school classes are smaller and give children more individual learning experiences. Children learn at their own pace, more help from teachers when a student doesn't understand what he is learning. Why should 13,000 + be given to Baldwin School District when they are doing a lousy job teaching our students and cared about our students learning. Plus home school district keep 20% of the money per cyber/charter student. They should have to turn that money over back to the state, federal government because they aren't teaching our students and not providing anything for them.

Comment_arrow

Matt A.

11:18 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

SWYKLocal if you are saying that in a cyber-environment a teacher should be able to handle 40 students then the same should apply to teachers in a Brick and Mortar School. Cyber Schools have a better ratio of teachers to students to give them a better individualize education.
The same cost per student in a Brick or Mortar School should be no more than 8K on what you are saying, but the school district keeps 20% of the money from the alloted amount. Baldwin is getting over 10,000 per student a year and when they have to send the money to a charter or cyber school for a student they are only sending a little over 8,000. Why shouldn't the full amount be sent with the student. That 2,000 that they are getting should be returned to the state if a child doesn't make use of joining sports or activities at the local school, but the School Districts keep the money.
If I had a children today in school, I would be opting to send my children to where the ratio of student/teacher is 9 students to 1 in a cyber/charter school than then 25-30/1 ratio in a Brick or Mortar School. I would expect students on this ratio getting a much better education than at your Brick or Mortar School.

Jon Wain

10:45 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

ouch on choke hold. but hats off to ya on the 5 children. lol you probably just started to get gray hair

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:30 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Jon I would really have to go on a search for a grey hair. Last time I seen one was about a year ago.

Jon Wain

10:48 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

cc did you ever consider school board position ?

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:37 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Jon, I work about 60 or more hours a week, with 1 in college, 1 military, 1 high school, 2 married with children, shopping, cleaning and a never ending laundry pile, I don't have more than a hour a week to go sit down at Eat N Park and meet my friends for coffee, but I do go to school board meetings when I can and also Whitehall Borough meetings. Some days I wished I took up drinking, but do know I am so better off that I don't.

Jon Wain

10:49 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

and same ? to that rampola fellow

Reply
Comment_arrow

Outraged Citizen

4:16 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@NE12Ukid – These are truly horrific instances indeed. I’m not sure if you’re meaning to extrapolate a nationwide crisis from two instances. But let’s take that approach. Let’s suppose that two instances are endemic of a nationwide problem with charter/cyber schools. Let’s paint with the broad bunch so many charter/cyber school detractors wish to employ. I'm interested to see where this leads us.

Following your logic, the recent story of improper behavior by a Pittsburgh school police officer must be an indicator of a larger looming problem. Throw in the recent stories of Western PA teachers engaging in inappropriate behavior with students – heck, the multitude of stories nationwide – and we have a real pandemic on our hands. We’re practically handing our children over to horrible, predatory monsters by sending them to public schools.

I don’t know about you NE12Ukid, but I would rather someone steal a little of my money than destroy my child’s innocence. That’s just me though, maybe you have different priorities.

Comment_arrow

cc

6:47 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

High school administrator in Chicago steals money for IEP
"CHICAGO (WLS) -- A Chicago elementary school that's come a long way in scholastic achievement is reeling after news that its former principal has been charged with stealing school money.

Mirna Diaz, a "superstar" principal in the Chicago Public Schools system faces 42 criminal counts for theft, forgery and unlawful conduct. Her lawyer says "extenuating circumstances" will explain her actions"
http://abclocal.go.com/wls/story?section=news/local&id=6071692

Detroit Public Schools principal, bookkeeper suspended over alleged misuse of funds
http://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20100223/FREE/100229957#
"Detroit Public Schools Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb has suspended the principal and bookkeeper at Randolph Career and Technical Center, alleging misuse of school funds.

The allegations stem from a DPS investigation led by Inspector General John Bell.
The investigation alleges that Principal Gwendolyn Miller used Randolph funds to make more than $29,000 in home mortgage payments between December 2006 and June 2009."

There are many more articles about theft in Public Schools then in Charter and Cyber Schools.

Look what happen to what 2 of the Fireman did from Baldwin Borough. It is a shame out there that any one has to steal. I always tell my children about stealing and if I ever caught them, I think I would turn them in because I didn't bring them up that way to be thieves.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

8:35 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Outraged, no, not at all. I only listed two linked sources, there are plenty more just do a Bing or Google.
and that extrapolation of two = many or all is your logic, not mine.
As to a child's innocence, one really has nothing to do with the other, as I was speaking of fraud of tax money, but since you bring it up, there's this (and more, of course):
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/02/suit-alleges-sexual-abuse_0_n_1644200.html
Sexual abuse at charter school

http://kilroysdelaware.wordpress.com/2011/06/12/delaware-governor-lets-child-abuser-operate-a-delaware-charter-school/
Child abuser opens charter school

http://www.caringforourchildrenfoundation.org/?p=5517
child abused by charter school teacher

http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/story?section=news/local&id=7451121
and from New York…

http://www.sptimes.com/2007/05/04/Northpinellas/Charter_school_admini.shtml
Charter school “leader” admits beating girl with belt.

Comment_arrow

Ed M

7:02 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

"High school administrator in Chicago steals money for IEP"

Where did this come from? What does stealing money have to do with an I.E.P.?

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

9:10 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

That must be from cc's post, right, Ed?

Comment_arrow

Outraged Citizen

12:15 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

@NE12Ukid – It’s really not surprising you didn’t quite get the gist of my post. You haven’t exactly been on speaking terms with reading comprehension and sound logic.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

6:23 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Dear mr outraged,
You wrote: " I’m not sure if you’re meaning to extrapolate a nationwide crisis from two instances. But let’s take that approach."
And I replied to you. NO NOT AT ALL, becasue I was not extrapolating any such thing.
Nothing wrong with my comprehension, just with your imaginary scenario.
so of course the answer is NO, not at ALL.
But thanks for playing. LOL

Comment_arrow

cc

8:47 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

NE12Ukid for every charter/cyber school article that you can find about someone having their hand in the cookie jar you can find 10 times that amount about Administrators, School board members, school staff having their hands in the cookie jar. It is everywhere that people steal money, banks, fire departments (2 from Baldwin Borough), just got busted within the last month. Theft is everywhere and it is a shame that anyone has to steal.

Comment_arrow

cc

8:49 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Ed- Ne12ukid is posting articles about people who work for cyber/charter schools stealing money so I was pointing out to him that it happens in Public Schools in many different places. It just isn't in Cyber/Charter schools that people steal. But she wanted to make a big stink out of it so I was proving to ml that theft is everywhere.

Comment_arrow

cc

8:52 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

ms ne12ukid, look what happen out in McKeeport the maintenance person worked for the school district and had a girl held hostage for how many years. South Park had a high school teacher busted for having sex with a student. Once again it isn't just in cyber/charter schools. There are a lot of sick people out there. So both points you are trying to make are invalid.

Comment_arrow

Ed M

6:54 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

I understand that, cc, but where is "High school administrator in Chicago steals money for IEP" in the article you quoted?

Comment_arrow

Outraged Citizen

1:00 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

@NE12Ukid – “mr outraged” is my father, please call me outraged.

“But thanks for playing,” punctuated with a “LOL” no less! You’re truly the literary wit of your generation! I can’t wait to see what gems you bring out next. Perhaps a “See ya, wouldn’t want to be ya!” Or maybe a “don’t let the door hit you on the way out!” I can only imagine that Mark Twain, George Orwell, Thomas More and the great Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. can now rest easy with the knowledge you have taken up their mantle.

Reading your post, it’s painfully obvious that you still don’t get it. That’s OK though, you’re just a kid. Perhaps when puberty sets in, your body goes through those awkward changes and you mature a little, you’ll get it. Until then, you and EC should be content with the kids table at Thanksgiving and let mommy and daddy have grown up time.

disappointed

1:07 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

NE12Ukid...I am not saying that the numbers are calculated properly. I dont know how they the came up with the dollar amounts. So maybe that formula needs to be reassessed. I think having vouchers like cc sugested would be a available better idea. If the Charter Schools are making a profit, they certainly take care of their students first! (at least at the one my child goes to) We couldn't be happier since she left the public school for the Charter School!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

6:56 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

disappointed does your charter school provide computers, books and internet service to your children. I know when my son and daughter in law signed my grandson up in VA, he was given a new laptop, all of his school books, notebooks, pens, pencils and then they asked my son and daughter in law if they had internet. If they didn't the school would of provided it for him to be able to be in school every day. He also goes on field trips with his class from cyber school once or twice a month. They have gone to zoo's, fire stations and have a trip planned for DC in the spring that the parents don't have to shell out any money for. None of the field trips cost money, the schools tuition pays for them.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

8:38 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

The cyber school is financed from our public school tax dollars. Unless things are VERY different in VA, there's no tuition being paid to a cyber charter.
And when they can afford all those extras which many of our public schools cannot, looks like another good argument for some critical reevaluation of the funding of such cyber charters.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

11:15 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I would add that I don't know that VA is having the same issues with the funding formulas and the accusations of misuse of funds that PA is having.

Comment_arrow

cc

9:05 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

What misuse of funding? If it cost 13,000 at Baldwin to send a student there then the same amount should be given to the Charter/Cyber school. Why should Baldwin keep any money when they are providing nothing to the student. The 20 % should be turned back over to the state or federal government and the home school district shouldn't be able to keep $2,600 out of it. It should cost the same amount to teach a child at a private, charter, public school in all districts.

Comment_arrow

cc

9:12 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

There is no tuition charged to go to a Public School either, but taxes on our homes, .5% of our income, Federal and State money pay for Public, Charter/Cyber schools. Va pays their charter/cyber schools the same way they pay public schools though taxes, just as they do in Pennsylvania and other states.

NE12Ukid

7:35 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Cyber is not the answer for everyone, but is certainly the best choice for some. Others thrive in a regular classroom, some others in a different kind of charter program, when done well many thrive via homeschooling. And yes, some students fail--in cyber school, charter, brick and mortar public school, Catholic school, homeschooling, etc. Tough job for parents to figure out what is best for their child, and realizing what works for child 1 may be the wrong fit for child 2.

Reply

bd

7:55 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Please explain from an education standpoint why a school district should offer cyber classes? I understand the money aspect but if something is offered via cyber that is of education benefit, then why not offer it in the classroom? I also believe the cyber education is supposed to be competion for brick-and-mortar education. If a school district offers cyber, what kind of competition is that? It simply offers the same education over a computer link. In B-W's case, an inferior product.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

7:01 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

bd I agree, I would not send my child to a charter school ran by Baldwin School District. There are many Charter and Cyber schools in PA that have high AYP scores as Peters and Upper St Clair. What is nice about cyber schools they do test your child and build their classes around it. As my grandson is taking classes in 3 grade levels.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

11:22 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

<<<bd
Please explain from an education standpoint why a school district should offer cyber classes? I understand the money aspect but if something is offered via cyber that is of education benefit, then why not offer it in the classroom?>>>

Good question, bd. As I see it, offering cyber classes could open up more possible classes. For example if only a few students in each school wanted to take a certain foreign language, and there was just one teacher who could teach that language, cyber classes could open those classes up to students in middle schools and high schools, maybe even some elementary or for the gifted or advanced students. To do this in brick and mortar school, that one teacher might not be able to travel back and forth to the different schools, there could be scheduling problems, might need to hire more teachers without enough students in each class to justify that expense; that sort of thing. But a cyber program could serve all the students who want to take that language, and they could progress through the program at their own pace.
I don't agree that it has to be a competition, instead it is an option, a choice. As said before, cyber school might be the best fit for one kid, but disastrous for another, as children (like adults) have a variety of learning styles.
If Baldwin doesn't offer any cyber classes, how can you know before a program is even chosen that it would be inferior?

Comment_arrow

cc

9:20 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

NE12Ukid Baldwin is inferior now as a brick and mortar school so do you actually think they would do better with cyber/charter school. I highly doubt it. What is nice about cyber school is students can go back and go over what was taught in the class. Students that are absent can go and see what was taught the day before if they have problem learning what was taught. Can't do that in a brick and mortar school. A parent can take their child on vacation with a cyber school and have their student in class every day without it being held against them. Parents and Students are held accountable also for their student being in class every day too.

Kathy McGrath McQuillan

8:20 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Something that seems to be ignored in the cyber school discussing is the drop out rate. I teach high school drop outs GED Prep. I work with kids who had issues with the traditional school. Many of them tried cyber school first but couldn't handle it.

If a student does not want to attend traditional school, what is going to motivate them to actually participate in the cyber school? I am talking about students who do not have parental support to complete their work.

Take a look at the yearly reports that our Dept of Education release. The graduation rates for the cyber schools are dismal.... between 30% and 60%. This is quite concerning.

I'm not saying cyber schools are not valuable. I simply dislike that they are marketed as the perfect fit for every/any kid.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mana

12:54 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

So, would you say the same for a B&M school graduation rate? Would you hold me to the same standards? I think there are more to the numbers...

Comment_arrow

cc

7:07 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Kathy from what I read, a child who spends all his life in charter or cyber school drop out rate is the same as going to a brick and mortar school. The ones that were thrown out of Public Schools are mostly placed in cyber or a charter school and these kids have issues with going to school. I have a neighbor who's daughter was in Baldwin and was busted up at the High School and was placed in cyber school. Her parents goes to work and she takes off to run the neighborhood and no one is there to make sure that she is doing her work. I do think Parents have to be more involved when you have a child at home doing cyber school, to make sure they are doing the work. My son and daughter in law both work on different shifts so that someone is at home with my grandson so that he gets his work done and isn't sneaking off into the living room to watch tv.

DormontMOM

8:51 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I think all school districts should have their "own" cyber school. It is a valuable option for children who for whatever reason do not want to attend the public school.
The money for these Cyber schools should stay in the school district. If you want your child in a different district, then you should pay tuition or move to that district, our school tax dollars should not be paying for it. The bottom line is if you are involved in your child's education then they will succeed, no matter what school they go to.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

7:15 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

The parents that have their child in cyber or charter school pay just the same amount of taxes as you do, so why shouldn't they use the money to send to a school of their choice The home school district gets to keep 20% of the money and they aren't teaching the child anything, which isn't fair to the person who chooses to send their child to cyber school. I wish they did have voucher programs because schools districts like Baldwin would be working harder to get their curriculum top notch to keep students instead of wasting and not giving our students a better education.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

8:41 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

VERY wise words, DormontMOM.

Bob Dove

9:02 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

There is a growing movement for the "blended" approach that is seeing good results. I teach blended classes at DeVry University and have experienced the benefits to students first hand. These classes meet with the teacher in a classroom once a week and then meet online the rest of the week. Students who aren't shy, speak out in the classroom and get their ideas heard. The less social students participate more online and shine in the online discussions. This blended approach for public education could cut down on the costs of running classrooms 5 days a week (including transportation), while enhancing the students' educational experience. The approach is much more adaptable to individualized instruction and it provides students with skills needed in the workplace (online teamwork projects, communicating electronically but professionally, etc.). The problem with an educational approach that would have kids at home during the day on a weekday, if a parent isn't there, still needs to be resolved for this solution to work across the board.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

11:28 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I believe that several area high schools do offer online learning opportunites, which would be another kind of "blending". There IS teacher interaction, whether it be in a classroom, via skype, or the written word.
For those students with working parents, they could do their cyber/internet classes when the parent gets home, or on the weekends, right?
Of course if those parents work 7-3 or 9-5 type job, no more free babysitting from the school district, eh?

Comment_arrow

cc

9:28 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

ne12ukid,no that isn't correct, they can't do school at a time they chooose. My grandson's cyber school starts at 8 am in the morning and is done at 2:30 ever4y day. He can't do his classes at night or when the parents are home after work. They have to be in classes just like a child going to a B & M school. If they miss so many days they are turned over to the magistrate just like someone going to a public school. That is why my son and daughter in law work different shifts so that someone is there when he is in school.
I'm glad you only send your children to school because they babysit your children but most people don't send their children to school for free babysitting, they send them to learn.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

1:05 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

We're talking about PA cyber charters here, not your grandkid's cyber in another state.
“self-paced” courses allow students to log in whenever they want, “virtual classroom” courses require students to log in together during certain set periods of time---PA cyber school has both FYI.
This article makes that clear if you read the first part, as well as letting us know about an area (in OUR STATE) where public school districts have started their own cyber charter, and also how 11 of the 13 cyber school districts chartered in Pennsylvania missed AYP last year.
Interesting reading:
http://www.pacyber.org/view-bulletin.jsp?restrictids=nu_repeatitemid&restrictvalues=2161392240601346055380435

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

1:07 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

I wrote: For those students with working parents, they could do their cyber/internet classes when the parent gets home, or on the weekends, right?
Of course if those parents work 7-3 or 9-5 type job, no more free babysitting from the school district, eh?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

cc didn't understand or misread and so wrote:
I'm glad you only send your children to school because they babysit your children but most people don't send their children to school for free babysitting, they send them to learn.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Wrong, cc. You probably see your error now.

Comment_arrow

cc

3:33 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

NE12Ukid - Not all charter cyber schools offer virtual classrooms in Pennsylvania. Pa Cyber School is one that offers these classes but they all don't offer them.

Ernie

9:17 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

I suppose it needs to be said.

While this debate is interesting, I don't see a lot of focus on the root of the problem, and that is how to improve schools that are not up to parents' expectations. In my opinion, Cyber Charter Schools could NOT exist if they did not receive unfair compensation from the Local School districts. Our district must pay over $13,000 per Cyber Charter School pupil. That is 80% of the PP costs of the district. That is NOT the incremental cost of educating one more child if they moved in to the district, that is our total budget divided by the number of students (roughly). Do you think Cybers are not money making machines??? Get real. Where do you think they get all that money for all the advertizing and the gross salaries of the "CEO"?

We need to get citizens involved in fixing their Public Schools. Period. We need to review Teacher Capabilities and reward them when they do great work. We need to revisit how we provide Pensions and Health Care Insurance to get them in line with the rest of the employees in America. If I could wave a magic wand, and take care of all of those issues, Cybers would not exist. They would not have a market.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sue T

5:45 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Erinie--I've been reading articles on this for months now, and in each, the school boards are in an uproar because of the money they need to pass on to charter schools (cybr or not). I have yet to see one school idstrict go after the root of the problem. Why are parents/students electing to attend charter (or private or moving) schools rather then the local school district, and what do we do to reverse that trend? Until the school boards start at least asking that question I find it dificult to see any problem with the money going to the charter schools. Obviously they can provide something the local district can not. And the districts haven't even acknowledged that there is a reason students are moving out.

Comment_arrow

cc

7:25 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Ernie of that 13,000 Baldwin gets to keep $2,600 (20%), when they aren't even supplying a bus to these students, nor a nurse if they get sick in school. Baldwin last year lost 200 students to Cyber Schools for the 2012-2013 school year and not sure how many parents didn't even register their child with the school district. With all the cuts to teaching for our students our school board and Administration needs to do better, but what did they do this year cut Technology budget. I can't fault any parent that pulls their child from Baldwin for a better Education.

Comment_arrow

cc

9:36 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Ernie, look at the money that our school is wasting on two Dean's of Sports. They were only given these jobs as a favor to someone on the school board. They are only there really to coach but getting big bucks.

Ernie how much money is the school district getting to keep for not education a child that is in Cyber/Charter school. 20%, that isn't fair either because they are doing nothing for the student who isn't even in the B & M school. Did you look at the salaries of members on our Administration and what they are paying teachers in the district that couldn't teach a dog to sit up and beg, yet they have a classroom full of students that learn nothing.

I do agree that teachers have to many perks and they do a lousy job of teaching our children. Tenure needs to go, it was great in the 1930-1960 but it just makes schools keep lousy teachers that would of been fired if they were working out in the real world.

SWYKLocal

11:28 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@Ernie
The curriculum followed in K-12 US schools was developed just after WWII. Subject order and content hasn’t changed much since then. If anything the learning standards have been drastically lowered with no accountability by administrator and teaching in our public leaning institutions.

I say so what if the cyber schools are making a profit just as long as they are providing an education that allows the person who receives an education from their school can become a productive contributing member of society.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ernie

2:55 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

The problem with the profit is that it comes at the expense of the local school district. You cannot ask community members to pay school taxes and then turn around and put that money in to some businessman's pocket. Right now, that is the fundamental funding issue that is in front of the Legislature.

As to curriculum, I think you are painting with way, way, way too wide a brush. I now have children in the school district I graduated from a millenia ago, and I can tell you quite surely that the curriculum is vastly different that when I attended.

Accountability is also undergoing changes in PA. The new LAW regarding teacher evaluations AND Administrator evaluations is in place. It wil be a struggle at the start, but it IS a step in the right direction.

As to standards being lowered, on a gutt level, I think I agree. I don't know if I could point to any quantitatve data to support that belief, but it just feels like it is so. I'm not sure there is a solution to the simple fact that different students will learn to different levels, and they must all be taught at the same school, sometimes in the same class, if the district is small.

SWYKLocal

4:05 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@Ernie
I agree, one hates to see tax money go towards profits, but if it helps move the public system forward it may not so bad short term.
Let me see if I can narrow my brush – the general course offerings are limited by grade (i.e. Geometry in the 8th grade and depending on the SD maybe Algebra II). These offering haven’t changed much since WWII. I can’t put my fingers on it, but I will see if I can find the link to my information source.

A good cyber system, could free course selection from grade level restrictions and could foster a “learn at your own pace system” (with minimum requirements and timeframes).

Good stuff – thanks for your reply.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Outraged Citizen

4:29 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@SWKYLocal – It’s interesting you would post, “. . . one hates to see tax money go towards profits.” Let’s take a look at that statement. If this were universally true, “one” would be compelled to “hate” the construction or the renovation of roads, bridges and public buildings – like schools – just to name a few. I won’t even get into the myriad of federal and state procurement opportunities that exist.

The government hires private companies to complete these tasks. How do they pay these companies you might ask? That’s right, taxpayer money. Do these companies complete these tasks to break even? No, they do it to make a profit. So, if “. . . one hates to see tax money go towards profits,” then “one hates” the above.

My apologies, but you statement defies logic.

Comment_arrow

cc

7:31 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Most contract that the Government write are time and material jobs. Companies make big profits off Government on these T & M jobs.

Comment_arrow

cc

9:44 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Outraged Citizen you made perfect sense. It is a shame that ne12ukids couldn't understand what you were saying. so she gets the booby prize, nothing for all the whining she does

SWYKLocal

4:35 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@Outraged Citizen -

Good point.

Reply

Jon Wain

7:42 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

What if our school grounds had a monument expressing the ten commandments since 1956 . ( recent news from south fayett.) some one complained and the attornies got involed (you know its all bout the MONEY BUT hey councler what does those dollar bills say on them .......hmmmmmmmm in god we trust. pretty soon santa clause will have to go. hmm this guy wants you to trust him in your home breaks in through the chimney) and bring s toy and goodies hmm so does your wife..

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

9:49 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Jon you are correct except

"A Fayette County church will likely salvage a controversial Ten Commandments monument and install it on its property -- less than a half-mile from the junior high where it now sits shielded by plywood.
The Connellsville Area school board will decide Wednesday whether the nearby Connellsville Church of God should receive the 5-foot monument.
There, it would still be visible from school grounds."

http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/local/neighborhoods-south/fayette-co-church-offers-to-take-disputed-monument-652752/#ixzz26JIbLcxe

one thing nice though where they are putting the monument that it can still be seen by middle school students.

Jon Wain

7:46 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

call me flint. he spark that etsyins rollin

Reply

Jon Wain

7:47 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

wow starting over hmm spark that gets yins rolling...there we go

Reply

Brian Rampolla

8:05 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Lots of good comments. I agree most with Ernie and Sue T that if indeed this district is losing a lot more kids to charter schools (I've not seen any official numbers), the board, administration, and teachers must immediately start working together to figure out why, which includes actively seeking parent and community input. But let me add that all of our musings on the Patch appear to be for naught and we should probably stop wasting our time. Why? Because the agenda for tomorrow nights board meeting does not include a single item addressing the issue of the PSSA scores and AYP. John Schmotzer specifically asked Dr. Lutz for some kind of plan to address this issue, so I would have expected this to be a priority to at least show us that they're serious about identifying the causes and implementing corrective actions. Silly me.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

9:17 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

... all of our musings on the Patch appear to be for naught and we should probably stop wasting our time. Why? Because the agenda for tomorrow nights board meeting does not include a single item addressing the issue of the PSSA scores and AYP. Brian Rampolla>>>>

I'd like to know why AYP on the PSSA is the only measure of school success.

Brian Rampolla

8:19 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

And let me add, it looks like tomorrows meeting could be long, with quite a few action and information items. Perhaps the PSSA/AYP issue will be discussed at the end, but we don't know. The only way to find out is to sit through the whole meeting. Of course we would not have to this if the meetings were broadcast, as just about every other modern district is doing. Doing so would allow many more people to understand the issues facing this district, which would be a great start to begin more community participation. Every week that goes by without broadcasting the meetings is just more evidence that the majority of this board just does not care. Come on John Schmotzer, put this issue on the agenda and let the community provide their comments and let the board members publicly debate the pros and cons.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

8:30 pm on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Brian I just have to wonder though when they talk about AYP and PSSA, their not going to go behind closed doors to do so, as they love to do. Tomorrow is my late night working and going to try to get to the meeting at some points because I have some questions I need answered that I have asked school board members and Administration and all I get from them is a run around.

disappointed

12:52 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

CC, My child goes to a Charter School, not a Cyber Charter School. So they don't provide lap tops etc. For all those who keep talking about Charter and Cyber Schools making a profit you need to do your homework. They have to be Non-profit. You can go to th Education Law office web site to confirm this. Maybe the Charter Schools are spending their money more appropriatey than the regular public schools which is why they offer more to the students than the public schools. I am sure that the unions aren't helping to keep public school costs down.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ernie

7:13 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

LOL! Non-profit???? Ok, ok, ok...I am pulling myself back together now...

Yes, I am sure they are all non-profits, just like UPMC is a non-profit. I stand corrected! LOL!

Comment_arrow

cc

9:58 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

disappointed, sorry I made a mistake on where your children go. I'm happy your child is getting a better education than what the B & M schools provide. I just know about the cyber school that my grandson is going to taking classes in 3 grades and that their cyber school in Va provides the students with laptop, books and everything they need for classes. At the end of the year they return the laptop and will get one back when they start classes for the next year.

disappointed

9:11 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Regardless of whether or not you believe they are non profit or not, Ernie, they are claasified as so. Regular public schools are non profit but I would say that the teachers, superintendent etc certainly are making a profit. Maybe if the publicschools spent their money a little more wisely then they would have more money to take care of the students. For example where my child goes, a Charter school, not cyber, they feed them a big breakfast before the PSSA's each day, out of the school's pocket. If they wanted to, they could have pocketed that money. This is just one example of what our Charter School does for our children. I would much rather my child go to a school where they are reaping the bebefits of the funding instead of just the teachers and administration. Until you experience both types of school like we have, I don't believe you really know what you are talking about. You can't just can't fo on what you hear in the media or hearsay.

Reply

NE12Ukid

10:04 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

disappointed:For all those talking about Charter and Cyber Schools making a profit you need to do your homework. They have to be Non-profit. You can go to th Education Law office web site to confirm this.>>>

I don't think for-profits should be funded with school tax moneys.The head of Pennsylvania Leadership Charter School is CEO, this is for profit enterprise. Some charters are non profit, others are run by for-profit corps.
The funding formula needs changing, the charters, especially cybers are making a profit.
Charters are not required to hire certified teachers. charter funding is being used for advertizing. Some charter schools re-evaluate students as special education, increasing the reimbursement rate.
In addition, charters (all PA charters) get paid twice for pensions. First from the PPE from each district which already includes this, and then charters get the districts' pension benefit on top of reimbursements they get for their own employees.
This double dipping is not illegal under the present system, but it should be. That's part of the current debate.
see: http://articles.mcall.com/2012-06-21/news/mc-pa-wagner-charter-school-20120620_1_cyber-charter-charter-schools-funding-formula
and
http://canon-mcmillan.patch.com/articles/tax-dollars-pay-for-cyber-charter-school-ads

Reply

disappointed

10:21 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Regardless, our Charter School takes much better care of their students than Moon ever did. If the public schools did this then maybe they wouldn't be in this predicament!

Reply

disappointed

10:31 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

NE12Ukid...I read the article. If it costs 13,000 something to fund a child in Public school then that that should follow each student to where ever they go. The state needs to adjust the amounts based on the real cost.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

6:43 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

No, I believe it said it costs about $13K-something for a CHARTER school student, and about 3K less for a cyber charter.
What follows the student is the PPE of his/her home district, which varies widely. So those kids in the cyber charters are not all "paying" the same amount.
If anything should follow a child, it MIGHT be the exact amount his/her parent actually paid in school taxes, which would not fund much of an education for anyone who does not own property (as cc's tenants in the 14 houses would have any school tax credit for their kids), and far from enough for one special needs child, or to educate children who have multiple siblings.
According to education.com BW spends $10,969 per pupil ;57% on instruction, 39% on support services, and 4% on other elementary and secondary expenditures.
A home owner in BW with a home assessed at 100K pays about 23-2400 in school taxes. Why should that homeowner get 4 or 5x that amount per kid?
It's taking more out than they paid in for sure.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

6:48 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Here's the quote from the article "PA Auditor General: Taxpayers overcharged $365 million annually for charter schools":
The result is Pennsylvania spends an average of $13,411 per student to attend a brick-and-mortar charter school.
That is about $3,000 above the per-student national average or $210 million extra annually.
Cyber schools cost Pennsylvania taxpayers an average of $10,145 per student, about $3,500 above the national average, or $105 million too much a year, according to Wagner.

Comment_arrow

cc

2:43 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

once again ml aka ne12ukid, leona has no clue what he is talking about. then again just need to ignore the ignorant as they don't know what they are talking about

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

1:21 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

Readers choice:
believe the linked and cited facts or believe the opinion above.

Brian Rampolla

1:13 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Good luck cc getting your questions answered by members of the the board at the board meeting. When George Pry was board president he established an official policy that board members will not engage in any discussion with members of the public during the public comment portion of the meeting, except of course if they like you and like what you're saying, then I've seen them gush all over certain people. I challenge them and question them and get nothing but blank stares.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

3:24 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

Brian I really wish I was at the meeting least night as I heard it was very amusing. I again called up to the Administration Building today to ask my questions but still being given the rur-a-round. Next month I am hoping to be able to make it to the school board meeting so that I can ask my questions that will totally shock some of the parents in the school.

JustMe

3:19 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

I live in Baldwin and my ex husband lives in Oakdale and over the summer I registeed my child at West Allegheny for 10th grade. I have been driving my son every day to school and his dad brings him back here at night after work. My son is very happy being at West Allegheny and says you can go into the bathrooms and not have to worry about students smoking cigarettes or pot in the bathrooms and students aren't having sex in the stairwells either between classes. He say he has learned more in less in a month at West Allegheny then in a year at Baldwin. They actually have money in their budget for Gifted Students to take college classes via a computer at CCAC. I never heard of Baldwin offering anything like this for Gifted Students. I am totally convinced now that Baldwin School District needs to get new administration, school board members and teachers that want to teach and not just their for paychecks and could care less about our students educations.

Reply

Heidi McDonald

10:23 am on Friday, September 28, 2012

I am another person with mixed feelings about this. What I'll say is that my personal experience with public high school was very difficult, it was a soul-sucking and painful experience I wouldn't wish on anyone, and if this is a way to give bullied kids an option to escape and still learn...or force bullies out of the school and into a program like this...it could make a real difference. There ARE resources available to cyberschooling families in order to provide social interactions, and, if your child lives in the school district, your child is still eligible to join extracurricular activities at the public school. Is this a magic fix? Hell, no. But...I am of the opinion that increasing options for children and families can't be a bad thing.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Matt A.

7:51 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

Parents that are pulling their children out of our school district are not the ones that have bad children, It is the good students and the students that are being picked on are being placed in cyber and charter schools. Soon it will be all the bullies, the students who could care less about learning and the trouble makers left in the school district. Can't wait to see next years school ranking now that a good portion of the smart kids were pulled out of the district.

NE12Ukid

4:52 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

Heidi, I like your idea of sending all the bullies to cyber school! Then the rest of the kids could attend their schools in a pleasant atmosphere. We'd probably even see achievement gains with the troublemakers removed from the school buildings.

Reply

NE12Ukid

9:17 am on Saturday, September 29, 2012

Since several here are hell-bent on disparaging the educational opportunities at our local public high school, maybe a few moments reflecting on some of the ACHIEVEMENTS and SUCCESSES is in order:
(from Patch article of recent months)
http://baldwin-whitehall.patch.com/articles/photos-best-brightest-honored-at-bhs-senior-awards-ceremony#photo-10128370

Reply

cc

5:52 pm on Saturday, September 29, 2012

i JUST LOVE HOW PEOPLE DON'T HAVE CHILDREN IN THE SCHOOL DISTRICT BUT THEY ARE AN EXPERT ON EVERYTHING THAT GOES ON UP AT THE SCHOOL.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ed M

1:30 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

That last post makes no sense cc and why are you yelling?

Comment_arrow

cc

4:34 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Ed it makes perfect sense since there is one on here that always comments on Baldwin yet has no children in the school and is the expert on the school board, administration, what goes on at the school on a daily bases. Prints partial articles then throws in a bunch of things that comes from other articles on a totally different subject and then tries to pass it off as its writing. Everything that they print comes fofrom a union that our school isn't even part of.. We as people that lived in Baldwin/Whitehall didn't support its child either when they went to Baldwin with our taxes, according to it, shim paid the whole tuition itself for her goats to go to the school distict

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

7:35 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

cc seems to have gone completely off the deep end now, with the yelling and then the rambling nonsensical accusations.
I believe this comes from cc's continuing insistence that every poster who disagrees with cc, is all ml, so far cc has said this about 8 or 9 different posters.
You're probably next, EdM. If so, welcome to the imaginary world of cc.

Comment_arrow

cc

8:51 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

no ne12ukid your just a stalker and loves to harass. You need to go find something to do with your life and get out of mine. You the expert on nothing and down at Frish on Saturday you once again were voted a nutcase and there are people in the medical field that think the same thing. You now make names up to pat yourself on the back when everyone knows it your writing. Cant wait till your obamacare puts you in the nuthouse where you belong.

Cindy Cusic Micco

11:24 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Remember the good old days when we were actually commenting on the subject of this story? It's "Should Local School Districts Open Their Own Cyber Schools?"

Let's get back to the good old days.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

11:35 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Sounds great, Cindy.
I just signed off on the one who took it off topic to rant and YELL, from here on in, s/he gets only prayers.

I'd like to see each district have a cyber school program, for those students who are unable to behave in class and who disrupt the learning of others, as well as for those students whose learning style meshes best with computerized instruction. Let the districts keep their funding while adding another layer of individualizing instruction for our students. One size does not fit all in education.

NE12Ukid

11:29 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

cc, just keep harassing me on every thread on every Patch, such as the one about the football game where I had not even visited until you had to bring my name into your posts three times. Maybe this will keep you off the streets so you won't bother others this way. As for me, I really don't care anymore, your just a sad, sad, possibly disturbed person. Go ahead and keep writing your lies and saying that ml is me I am ml, I am Leona, Erin, Mike, PITT, brute, bangtime, etc etc.
There is no picture of you so clear as the one you paint here of yourself.
May God soothe your tortured soul.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cc

9:20 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Sorry Ne12ukid your are the harasser and you stalk me on every article that I post on. You have no life and are a bully and thank goodness your not on the streets, then again I feel bad for your neighbors as they probably run when they see you outside.

Comment_arrow

NE12Ukid

1:22 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

There is no picture of you so clear as the one you paint here of yourself.
May God soothe your tortured soul.

Patch_comments_icon

Zandy Dudiak

9:43 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Please, let's keep the personal comments off this thread. This is here to discuss the issues of interest to our community, not as a place to harass each other.

Reply

NE12Ukid

1:30 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

Zandy, if editors would remove cc's post every time she starts this, there would be no need to respond to the lies and harassment, right?
starting with
cc 1:39 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012
cc 2:43 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
cc 5:52 pm on Saturday, September 29, 2012

and even inserts her snarky comments using my name on articles I had not even read let alone commented on yet.
She ran one poster off the PATCH and is apparently trying to do the same to others. But I see your point, and will just continue to pray for some peace for her, for whatever compels her to continue like this.

As I said to Cindy:
I'd like to see each district have a cyber school program, for those students who are unable to behave in class and who disrupt the learning of others, as well as for those students whose learning style meshes best with computerized instruction. Let the districts keep their funding while adding another layer of individualizing instruction for our students. One size does not fit all in education.

Reply

NE12Ukid

6:08 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

MattA asked: Baldwin is getting over 10,000 per student a year and when they have to send the money to a charter or cyber school for a student they are only sending a little over 8,000. Why shouldn't the full amount be sent with the student.>>>

A report on 14 schools in those two counties shows that they are giving up from $6,828 to $11,000 for each of their students enrolled in cyber charter schools, an amount determined by the school's average cost per student. That amount increases to as much as $25,000 for special education students, according to the report.
The tuition for a student living in one Pennsylvania district who is enrolled in a public cyber charter school might be...
(continued)

Reply

NE12Ukid

6:09 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

... thousands of dollars different from that for a similar student enrolled at the same school who lives in another district in the state.

And Pennsylvania school districts are paying a tuition rate to send a student to a cyber charter school that is often much higher than the actual cost to educate the student.

The superintendents at schools that have started their own cyber schools to keep their students in house say the average cost of educating those students is around $4,200.
The report suggests that the state require the districts to pay the lowest per-student cost rate in the region for each student attending other schools [the $6,828 paid by Panther Valley]
OR...

Reply

NE12Ukid

6:10 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

...the $4,200 per student they say they pay for the service.
The arguments: Districts shouldn't be paying different rates for the same service and cyber schools operate at a "fraction" of brick and mortar schools.
As reported in an earlier PATCH article, any bill to reform financing of charter/ cyber charter schools should address4 key areas:
1. Limiting unassigned fund balances for charter/cyber charter schools consistent with limits already in effect for traditional public schools. 2010, auditor general reported charter schools had $108 million reserve funds. Nearly 1/2 of charter schools had reserve fund balance above public schools' limit of 12 %of annual spending. Charter balances were as high as 95 %
(continued)

Reply

NE12Ukid

6:10 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

...•Removing "double dip" for pension costs by charter schools. School district's cost for retirement expenditures is not subtracted from expenditures in calculation that determines funding for charters and sets up a "double dip" since state law guarantees charter schools reimbursement for retirement costs. The PA Association of School Business Officials estimates between 2011-12 and 2016-17, eliminating "double dip" would save school districts $510 million.
•Limiting special education funding that a charter school receives per student to its school district's total per-pupil spending for sped services. The state funding formula's 16-percent cap on school district sped population does not apply to charter schools.
•Requiring year-end audits by Department of Education to determine actual costs of education services of charter schools, an annual year-end final reconciliation of tuition payments from school districts against actual costs , overpayments to be returned to the school districts.

Reply

Leave a comment